OurChurchOS vs. Tithely

Tithely starts with free giving and sells church management, an app and a website one by one or in a bundle. OurChurchOS puts giving, check-in, streaming, your website, a store and an office suite on one plan.

Start your free trial

The short version

Tithely Giving has no monthly fee; you pay processing on each gift. Church management is $72 a month, a church app $89 and a website $19, or $119 a month for all of them in Tithely All Access.

With OurChurchOS, giving is part of every plan and gifts go straight into your church's own Stripe or Square account. Growth, at $149 a month, covers check-in, service planning, texting, live streaming, a member portal, an online store, e-signatures and a full office suite. Tithely All Access costs less; OurChurchOS covers more of what a church runs on.

Side by side

TithelyOurChurchOS
PriceGiving free; church management $72, app $89 and website $19 a month, or All Access $119 a monthStarter $32, Growth $149, Established $479 a month; Enterprise by quote
Getting started30-day free trial on paid plans14-day free trial on Starter, Growth and Established
Online giving2.9% + $0.30 per card gift, 1% + $0.30 per bank transfer and 3.5% + $0.30 for American Express; donors can cover the feeIncluded in every plan, with no OurChurchOS fee. Gifts go straight into your church's own Stripe or Square account at its own rate: Stripe's standard is 2.9% + $0.30 per card gift, and 0.8% capped at $5 per bank account gift with Stripe. Donors can choose to cover the fee
Where gifts goTithely deposits gifts to your bank account, daily on All AccessStraight into your church's own Stripe or Square account, which pays your bank on the schedule you choose there
Admin usersUnlimited on paid plansUnlimited staff logins on every plan
Kids check-inIncluded in All AccessIncluded from Growth
Text messaging100 texts a month free on All AccessIncluded from Growth
Service and worship planningIncluded in All Access, with a worship appService and rundown planning included from Growth
Church app or member portalCustom church app, $89 a month or in All AccessMember portal from Growth, in the browser with nothing to install
Your website$19 a month, or in All AccessA one-page site on Starter, three pages on Growth, a full website builder on Established
Live streamingNot in Tithely's published plansIncluded from Growth
Documents, spreadsheets, presentations and moreNot in Tithely's published plansIncluded in every plan: documents, spreadsheets, presentations, databases, notes, drawings and music scores, shared with your staff and volunteers (10 of each on Starter, 50 on Growth, 250 on Established, unlimited on Enterprise)
Online store and in-person salesNot in Tithely's published plansIncluded from Growth: sell books, shirts and tickets online or at a welcome desk with a Square reader, paid straight into your church's own account
BookkeepingNot in Tithely's published plansIncluded from Established

Tithely prices and rates are from tithe.ly as published on October 15, 2026. Prices change, so please check their site for current pricing.

When Tithely may be the better fit

We would rather you choose well than choose us. Tithely is a good choice if your church:

• Only needs online giving, with no monthly fee.

• Wants a custom app members install on their phones.

When OurChurchOS is the better fit

OurChurchOS is likely the better choice if:

• You want gifts to go straight into your church's own Stripe or Square account.

• You want live streaming, an online store and an office suite alongside giving and check-in.

• You want your website, member portal and records in one place with one login.

• Your givers make large gifts from their bank accounts: Stripe's 0.8% is capped at $5, so a $1,000 gift costs $5 to receive instead of $10.30 at Tithely's 1% + $0.30.

See plans and start a free trial

Try it before you switch

Start a free trial and set OurChurchOS up alongside the tools you use today, so you can see it working for your church before you change anything. Questions about moving over? We are happy to walk you through it.

Talk with us

Tithely is a trademark of its owner. OurChurchOS is not affiliated with or endorsed by Tithely.